About
Mayfair Stamp Company is one of the Midwest's most trusted philatelic dealers, operating since 2010 out of Appleton, Wisconsin. With a family legacy spanning three generations and over 70 years in the stamp trade, they bring unmatched expertise in assessing, buying, and selling U.S. and worldwide stamps, postal covers, postal stationery, postal history, historical documents, and ephemera. The company processes over 100,000 items annually and maintains an extensive network of serious collectors and dealers worldwide, enabling them to offer competitive prices to sellers. They are recognized as one of the largest postal cover dealers in the country, with a broad and loyal customer base. Sellers can take advantage of free collection valuations, immediate cash payments, and flexible options including walk-in visits, nationwide shipping, or scheduled consultations. For buyers, the company operates an online store with over 5,000 new items listed weekly, as well as an eBay store. Mayfair also provides a comprehensive online Stamp Selling Guide for both novices and experienced collectors, covering topics such as inherited collections, postal cover basics, and best practices for liquidating philatelic holdings. Whether you're looking to sell a single inherited album or reduce a large dealer inventory, Mayfair Stamps offers a seamless, knowledgeable, and customer-focused experience.
Key Features
- Free Collection Valuations: Mayfair offers no-cost appraisals for stamp and postal cover collections of any size, giving sellers an honest market assessment before committing.
- Nationwide Buying Service: Collections can be purchased from anywhere in the U.S. via shipping or in-person visits, with immediate cash payments available.
- Online Store with 5,000+ Weekly Listings: Buyers can browse a constantly refreshed inventory of stamps, covers, and postal history items through the company's online store and eBay presence.
- Stamp Selling Guide: A free educational resource covering how to sell stamp and philatelic collections, tailored for both novices and experienced collectors.
- Expert Consultations: Scheduled one-on-one consultations with experienced specialists help collectors make informed decisions about buying or selling their philatelic items.
Use Cases
- Selling an inherited stamp collection quickly and conveniently for a fair cash price.
- Dealers looking to reduce or liquidate excess philatelic inventory through a trusted buyer.
- Collectors seeking to purchase rare U.S. or worldwide stamps and postal covers online.
- Novice collectors learning how to value and sell their first stamp collection using the free Stamp Selling Guide.
- Postal history enthusiasts looking to buy or sell first-day covers, postal stationery, and historical documents.
Pros
- 70+ Years of Family Expertise: Three generations of philatelic knowledge ensure accurate assessments and fair pricing for even the most complex collections.
- Immediate Cash Payments: Sellers receive prompt cash offers for collections large and small, removing the uncertainty of consignment or auction timelines.
- Extensive Buyer Network: As one of the largest postal cover dealers in the country, Mayfair can offer top prices backed by a large, diverse base of serious collectors.
Cons
- Primarily Midwest-Focused Walk-In Service: Physical walk-in appraisals are only available at their Appleton, Wisconsin location, limiting in-person access for non-Midwest sellers.
- No Real-Time Online Pricing: Sellers must contact the company or book a consultation to receive a valuation; there is no instant automated pricing tool on the website.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I sell my stamp collection to Mayfair Stamps?
You can sell your collection by visiting their Appleton, Wisconsin office (walk-ins welcome), shipping your items to them, or booking a consultation online to discuss the process.
Does Mayfair Stamps buy collections outside of Wisconsin?
Yes, Mayfair purchases stamp and postal cover collections nationwide. Sellers can ship their collections or arrange for a remote appraisal.
Is the collection valuation really free?
Yes, Mayfair provides free valuations with no obligation to sell, whether you visit in person or inquire remotely.
What types of items does Mayfair buy?
They buy U.S. and worldwide stamps, postal covers, postal stationery, postcards, postal history, historical documents, ephemera, and entire dealer inventories.
Where can I buy stamps and covers from Mayfair?
Mayfair offers items through their own online store, which is updated with 5,000+ items weekly, as well as through their eBay store.
